Monitoring in Prisons Using Artificial Intelligence
govciooutlook

Monitoring in Prisons Using Artificial Intelligence

Government CIO Outlook | Tuesday, October 25, 2022

Legislators should be cautious when expanding the use of artificial intelligence, given its shortcomings.

FREMONT, CA: As artificial intelligence (AI) has become more powerful and accessible, governments have become increasingly interested in its potential benefits. A fiercely contested application of AI is monitoring talks between inmates and outside callers within jails and correctional facilities to identify specific words or phrases that may indicate danger for inmates.

Stay ahead of the industry with exclusive feature stories on the top companies, expert insights and the latest news delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.

Reuters reported that a group of congressional lawmakers made a request to the Department of Justice requesting a report on the potential use of AI in federal prisons, indicating that lawmakers may be receptive to the concept of implementing this technology on a wide scale. Reuters' David Sherfinski and Avi Asher-Schapiro wrote:

A crucial House of Representatives panel has requested a report on using AI to analyze prisoners' phone calls, paving the way for prisons in the United States to receive more technological assistance in monitoring inmate speech.

Families and advocates for prisoners argue that depending on AI to interpret messages leaves the system vulnerable to errors, misunderstandings, and racial bias.

The request for the Department of Justice (DOJ) to further investigate the technology to help prevent violent crime and suicide is included in an $81 billion-plus budget package for the DOJ and other federal agencies in 2022 that was approved by the Appropriations Committee last month.

The device can automatically transcribe inmates' phone calls by studying their communication patterns and detecting specific words or phrases, including slang, that are pre-programmed into the system by officials.

In an emailed statement, a Democratic staffer to the House of Representatives urged the Department of Justice to "consult with stakeholders while considering the viability of employing such a system."

Several state and local facilities around the nation, including Alabama, Georgia, and New York, have already begun implementing the technology.

Current problems with AI in prisons indicate early efforts to adopt the software may offer more risks than benefits. Comparing talks is hampered by the limited data available to the software in the current state of AI call monitoring. Developers focused on popular languages and dialects in the early days of analyzing language with AI. As a result, contemporary AI that investigates conversations struggles to comprehend some communication formats more than others.

This aspect of contemporary AI becomes troublesome when its usage in the criminal justice system is considered. Although most Americans speak English, there are over 30 primary varieties of American English. Currently, a significant proportion of inmates in American prisons do not talk about the kind of English that many developers train AI systems to recognize. According to research, AI constantly misinterprets African American English (AAE) compared to other dialects. According to a new study by Stanford Engineering, the technology that drives the nation's premier automatic speech recognition systems makes twice as many mistakes when interpreting words uttered by African Americans than when interpreting the exact words spoken by whites.

As a result, the use of AI in its current form may unwittingly discriminate against certain persons by flagging more of their discussions for human review than others. Consequently, utilizing AI in prisons before the technology can accurately catalog all offenders' languages would undoubtedly cause issues for populations already subject to discrimination.

The second obstacle to growing the use of AI in correctional facilities is not the technology's limitations but rather the extent to which management should rely on AI for effective oversight. AI can assist personnel in doing jobs more efficiently; nonetheless, correctional institution administrators should avoid responding to present challenges by depending excessively on AI in jail management. When the AI flags a communication, there must be a legitimate review and appeal process; it cannot be assumed that the AI system is always correct.

The labor-saving potential of AI has already attracted the attention of correctional administrators across the nation. As in other industries, technology has brought significant advancements to the field of corrections, but an over-dependence on new surveillance methods for convicts might have harmful effects. Instead of providing enough accommodations for convicts with COVID-19, New Orleans invested $70 million in technologically advanced camera upgrades.

Even if callers know that AI software is on the line, failure to physically supervise external calls may pose safety risks for inmates. Even if AI were capable of comprehending all inmates' calls, it is possible that some convicts would attempt to mislead the program, just as some inmates attempt to smuggle contraband into institutions or continue outside criminal operations while confined. Suppose officials opt to rely solely on AI to monitor phone calls. In that case, convicts might easily use codewords or other methods to circumvent AI software, making it easier for them to plot risky activities that could endanger inmates and cops. On the other hand, AI that incorrectly identifies innocent terms as problematic may result in unjust punishment of inmates.

However, policymakers should not overreact by concluding that the technology should be outlawed due to the genuine flaws of AI as it exists today. Researchers are already addressing some practical challenges associated with deploying AI to monitor prisoner discussions. If AI reaches the level of sophistication required to monitor prisoner discussions successfully and corrections staff accept it as a tool rather than a replacement, the technology might be revolutionary.

Additionally, a complete ban on the use of AI in jails would prevent prisoners from benefiting in the future from this technology. In a population where at least half of individuals are mentally ill and where present prisons only raise the likelihood of acquiring mental illness and further behavioral difficulties, we should pursue technologies that allow us to enhance the health of prisoners across the nation.

Before permitting expansions of AI's use, legislators should be cautious of the technology's existing flaws, but they must also avoid prematurely limiting this technology's future life-saving potential.

More in News

Public trust is essential for any effective public safety agency. It has been cultivated over decades through a rigorous accreditation process that includes professional standards, independent reviews, and verified compliance, serving as a benchmark for commitment to excellence. However, the traditional accreditation model, while admirable in its goals, is often characterized by its cyclical and manual nature, requiring significant preparation over the years and culminating in an intense on-site assessment where auditors manually sift through large volumes of paperwork, policy binders, and case files. Achieving accreditation is a badge of honor, but it traditionally represents a snapshot in time. It certifies that an agency met the standards on the assessment days. In a world that now moves at the speed of data, this periodic, rear-view-mirror approach is giving way to a more dynamic, continuous, and intelligent paradigm: Accreditation as a Service, powered by the transformative capabilities of Artificial Intelligence (AI). From Static Review to Continuous Readiness The first significant shift is conceptual, moving from accreditation as a product —a certificate earned every few years—to Accreditation as a Service. This model leverages cloud-based platforms that digitize and centralize an agency's policies, procedures, and evidence of compliance. Think of it as a living, breathing digital dashboard for agency health, replacing the static, dusty binders of the past. In this Accreditation-as-a-Service framework, readiness is not a "scramble" every three or five years; it's a permanent state. When an accreditation body updates a standard, the AaaS platform reflects that change instantly, notifying key personnel of the new requirement. This service-oriented model provides the vehicle for continuous improvement, but it is Artificial Intelligence that provides the engine. AI is the catalyst that moves this model from a simple digital filing cabinet to a proactive, intelligent partner in public safety. The AI Engine: Reshaping the Mechanics of Compliance AI is revolutionizing the Accreditation-as-a-Service model, infusing it with capabilities that were once the realm of science fiction. By automating labor-intensive administrative tasks and deriving new insights from existing data, AI is transforming the way agencies approach accreditation and compliance. One of the most significant advancements lies in the intelligent automation of evidence gathering—a historically time-consuming aspect of accreditation. Agencies have long been required to provide tangible proof that field practices align with written policies. Today, AI, particularly through Natural Language Processing (NLP), is making this process remarkably efficient. These systems can read and interpret unstructured text within incident reports, dispatch logs, and internal memos. For example, an AI can scan a newly filed report, identify it as a specific type of event—such as a use-of-force incident or a citizen complaint—and automatically tag it as evidence relevant to multiple standards. It can even cross-reference personnel records to verify training compliance and flag discrepancies for review. This level of automation not only eliminates thousands of hours of manual data processing but also allows personnel to focus on their core mission rather than administrative documentation. Beyond automating tasks, AI is propelling a shift from reactive to predictive compliance. Traditional audits reveal issues after they occur, while AI-driven systems anticipate and prevent them. By analyzing vast datasets—including dispatch times, incident types, personnel histories, and even public sentiment—machine learning models can detect subtle patterns and early indicators of potential non-compliance. An AI system might, for instance, identify gradual increases in response times within a particular district or correlate procedural errors with a recent policy update. Armed with this foresight, agency leaders can address emerging issues proactively through targeted training or policy clarification, transforming compliance into a forward-looking risk management practice rather than a retrospective evaluation. AI is also redefining policy and procedure management, an area often challenged by complex and evolving legislative requirements. An AI-powered Accreditation-as-a-Service platform can instantly review an agency’s policy manual—sometimes hundreds of pages long—against new state regulations or updated accreditation standards. It can pinpoint outdated clauses, flag inconsistencies, and even recommend revised language aligned with best-practice templates. This ensures that policies remain not only compliant but also coherent, current, and internally consistent. Elevating the Standards Themselves The impact of AI extends beyond helping agencies meet standards; it is now helping accreditation bodies create them. For the first time, accrediting organizations can analyze aggregated, anonymized data at scale. By analyzing trends across hundreds of agencies, they can gain data-driven insights into which standards have the most tremendous positive impact on outcomes. They can identify which policies are most effective in practice, not just in theory. This allows for the evolution of standards based on empirical evidence, moving away from consensus-based committee decisions and toward a truly data-informed model of public safety excellence. The standards themselves become "living standards," adapting to the proven realities of modern field operations. The future points toward a deeply integrated ecosystem where accreditation is no longer a separate function but a seamless, autonomous background process. AI-driven Accreditation as a Service is fostering a fundamental culture shift. It is moving public safety from a mindset of periodic compliance to a culture of continuous improvement. The goal is no longer just to pass the test but to create intelligent, agile, and transparent organizations that earn public trust every single day. This is the new benchmark for excellence, written in data and powered by intelligence. ...Read more
Over the past few decades, correction policies have developed in response to changes in societal norms, advances in technology, and a growing emphasis on rehabilitation. These policies are designed to prioritize human needs and rely on data, demonstrating a strong commitment to reducing recidivism through innovative approaches. Correctional practices in the modern world incorporate punitive models in rehabilitation frameworks. Traditional methods involve incarceration and other forms of confinement, which often prove ineffective. Future policies focus on education, vocational training, and mental health so inmates can effectively reintegrate into society after serving their sentences. Most of these changes are systemic, with issues such as poverty and poor mental health diagnoses. Integrating technology in corrections transforms operations, as predictive analytics identify individuals at a higher risk of recidivism, and digital monitoring systems like ankle bracelets reduce overcrowding. Virtual reality programs are emerging as a tool for rehabilitation, providing immersive experiences to teach conflict resolution and job skills in a controlled environment. Community-based corrections programs are now gaining popularity as alternatives to the traditional incarceration of offenders. Probation, parole, and restorative justice programs are more about accountability and reintegrating into the community than isolation. Restorative justice aims explicitly to heal the harm that crime has caused through facilitated dialogue between victims and offenders. It helps in evoking empathy and mutual understanding and can significantly reduce reoffending. Mental health and substance abuse treatment are becoming cornerstones of corrections policies. Increasing recognition of the intersection between mental health issues and criminal behavior has led to the expansion of specialized courts and diversion programs. These initiatives focus on treatment rather than punishment for individuals whose offenses are closely tied to mental health or addiction struggles. Such policies address the needs of the individual while also alleviating the burden on overcrowded correctional facilities. Public perception and advocacy are cornerstones of future corrections policies. Grassroots activism and advocacy groups are increasingly determining criminal justice system legislation. Public opinion and advocacy are forging a way toward more humane and equitable policies from lawmakers who recognize that citizens want justice. Systemic inequalities continue to be a significant concern, particularly regarding racial disparities in imprisonment rates. Future legislation should address and reduce these inequalities to ensure that justice is equitable, from the point of arrest through to sentencing. The future of corrections policies will be characterized by rehabilitation, technology integration, and community involvement. These changing policies address systemic issues while upholding human dignity, and they seek to reform the corrections system to serve individuals and society better. ...Read more
FREMONT CA:  Promoting fair access to digital services in government is essential for ensuring that all citizens can fully participate in the digital economy and benefit from technology's convenience and efficiency. The digital divide has emerged as a critical challenge, exacerbating existing inequalities in access to information and resources as governments increasingly transition to online platforms for delivering public services. To address this issue, it is vital to implement inclusive policies that prioritise accessibility, affordability, and digital literacy, ensuring that marginalised and underserved communities are not left behind. Inclusivity in digital access means providing every citizen with equal opportunities to engage with government services. When digital services are accessible to all, it fosters social and economic inclusion, allowing everyone to contribute to and benefit from digital advancements. By promoting equitable access to digital services, governments can enhance civic engagement, improve service delivery, and build trust among citizens, ultimately creating a more just and responsive public sector. Strategies for Bridging the Digital Divide and Enhancing Access to Government Services Efficiency Through Digital Services Digital services streamline government operations, making them more efficient and cost-effective. Governments can deliver services more quickly and uniformly by reducing paperwork and automating processes. Ensuring all citizens have access to these digital services can enhance overall efficiency, enabling governments to serve the public better and allocate resources more effectively. Enhancing Transparency and Accountability Digital platforms can significantly enhance transparency and accountability in government operations. By making information more accessible and processes more traceable, digital services help build trust between the government and its citizens. This transparency is crucial for fostering a more open and accountable government that operates in the public's best interests. RedactX supports this objective by enabling secure document redaction and controlled information sharing, ensuring agencies maintain openness while protecting sensitive data. Investing in Infrastructure Investing in broadband infrastructure is crucial to bridging the digital divide, particularly in underserved rural and remote areas. Public-private partnerships can play a significant role in expanding internet coverage. Governments can improve infrastructure to ensure that even the most isolated communities can access digital services, promoting greater equity and inclusion. CSS partners with public sector organizations to strengthen governance, operational strategy, and policy implementation frameworks. By aligning technology modernization with accountability standards and performance metrics, CSS helps agencies improve service delivery while maintaining regulatory compliance and public trust. Making Access Affordable Affordable access to the internet and digital devices is essential for lower-income households. Governments can collaborate with technology companies to provide subsidised rates or low-cost devices, ensuring that financial barriers do not prevent citizens from accessing digital services. Affordable access is critical to bridging the digital divide and promoting digital inclusion. Boosting Digital Literacy Digital literacy programmes are essential for empowering individuals to use digital services effectively. These initiatives should target those most affected by the digital divide, such as older people and individuals with low levels of formal education. By improving digital literacy, governments can ensure that all citizens are equipped to engage with and benefit from digital services. Designing for Accessibility Government websites and digital platforms must be designed with accessibility in mind. This means creating user-friendly interfaces that are easy to navigate, even for people with disabilities or limited digital skills. Accessible design ensures that all citizens can use digital services effectively, promoting greater inclusion and equity. Leveraging Mobile Technology With mobile phones' high penetration, especially in developing regions, mobile-friendly services can enhance accessibility. Developing mobile apps and SMS-based services allows governments to reach a broader audience, ensuring that more citizens can access essential services regardless of location or digital literacy level. Policy and Regulation Developing policies that promote digital inclusion and enforcing regulations that ensure fair access to digital services are fundamental steps in addressing the digital divide. Governments must monitor and evaluate the effectiveness of these policies, making adjustments as needed to ensure they are achieving their goals. Effective policy and regulation are essential for fostering a more inclusive digital society. A Collaborative Effort Bridging the digital divide requires sustained and collaborative efforts from governments, the private sector, non-profits, and international organisations. These stakeholders can develop and implement effective strategies to promote digital inclusion by working together. Collaboration is vital to ensuring that all citizens can benefit from the advantages of digital transformation. By prioritising inclusivity through investments in infrastructure, affordability, digital literacy, and accessible design, governments can ensure that all citizens, regardless of their background or circumstances, can participate in the digital economy. These efforts further bolster Transparency and accountability, fostering trust between citizens and their government. However, addressing the digital divide requires a collaborative approach involving partnerships across sectors and ongoing policy development to adapt to the changing landscape. As the digital future advances, the commitment to equitable access to digital services will be essential for building a more just and responsive society that empowers every citizen to thrive in the digital age. ...Read more
FREMONT CA:  Advancing digital services in government through the integration of new technologies is essential for enhancing efficiency, transparency, and accessibility. As citizens increasingly expect seamless digital experiences, governments worldwide are leveraging innovations like artificial intelligence, cloud computing, and blockchain to improve service delivery, streamline processes, and foster more responsive interactions with the public. Forward-looking CIOs are guiding their governments in incorporating new technologies into the digital services they offer citizens. These technologies represent a natural progression for the role of government CIOs, transforming them from traditional caretakers of IT infrastructure to comprehensive brokers of digital services. This shift requires CIOs to take a holistic approach to digital transformation, ensuring that emerging technologies are effectively integrated to meet evolving public needs. While CIOs are embracing new technologies, the foundational responsibilities of ensuring core IT functions such as storage, network operations, and system reliability remain essential. As they integrate emerging technologies, CIOS must manage these functions effectively to minimise risk and ensure smooth operations. By considering strategic actions that optimise digital transformation, CIOs can help their organisations evolve without compromising the stability and security of critical infrastructure. Strategic Approaches to Integrating Emerging Technologies in Organisations Embracing Emerging Technology Through Strategic Design Organisations are encouraged to adopt emerging technology thoughtfully, ensuring decisions are intentional rather than reactive. A cross-agency forum for information sharing and discussions on technological advancements can help guide enterprise decision-making with a collaborative approach. Integrating Emerging Technology into Enterprise Architecture Emerging technologies must be methodically incorporated into an organization’s enterprise architecture to ensure alignment with long-term strategic objectives. By clearly documenting the intended direction for each technology domain and identifying relevant innovation trends, agencies can establish a structured framework that supports scalable and sustainable digital transformation. Trustonics operates in secure, architecture-driven technology environments where disciplined system integration and governance oversight are central to maintaining performance and compliance. Embedding emerging capabilities within a defined enterprise architecture reduces fragmentation, strengthens interoperability, and enables more consistent innovation across departments. Establishing an Innovation Fund for Technology Adoption Funding mechanisms can be adapted to support emerging technology by framing acquisitions as operating expenses rather than capital expenditures. Allocating a portion of the charge-back budget to an innovation fund or seeking appropriations for grant-based funding models allows agencies to pilot new technologies with reduced financial risks. RFSignalman provides advanced wireless and RF infrastructure solutions that support secure communications and mission-critical connectivity within government operations. Streamlining Procurement for Emerging Technology Procurement processes can be adjusted to facilitate research and pilot projects. Developing language that permits waivers for competitive bids during proof-of-concept stages can accelerate innovation. This approach helps document requirements for subsequent competitive proposals while encouraging experimentation. Showcasing Technology Through Vendor Demonstrations Vendors can be invited to establish innovation centres that demonstrate the practical applications of emerging technologies. These centres allow agencies to explore how new tools and systems can address business challenges and enhance digital services. Encouraging Cross-Agency Collaboration on Pilot Projects Piloting emerging technologies across common business functions can benefit agencies. Facilitating cross-agency collaboration and information sharing ensures standardisation on platforms and capabilities while driving consistent innovation. Empowering Front-Line Departments in Technology Adoption The success of emerging technologies often depends on their alignment with real-world needs. Front-line departments can identify business challenges and work with enterprise IT to pilot and deploy solutions within the broader enterprise architecture. This bottom-up approach fosters greater acceptance and long-term success. By adopting a thoughtful, collaborative approach, government CIOs can ensure that technologies such as AI, cloud computing, and blockchain are incorporated effectively into public services while maintaining core IT functions. Governments can accelerate the adoption of new technologies through strategic design, innovation funds, streamlined procurement, and cross-agency collaboration. Empowering front-line departments to drive technology adoption ensures that these innovations are aligned with real-world needs, fostering a more responsive, agile, and future-ready government that can better serve its citizens. ...Read more

Weekly Brief